Determinants of Empowerment: Evidence from Tribal Women in Jammu and Kashmir

 

Irfan Rasool1*, Sourabh Vyas2

1Research Scholar, Department of Sociology, Bhagwant University, Ajmer, Rajasthan, India.

2Associate Professor, Department of Sociology, Bhagwant University, Ajmer, Rajasthan, India.

*Corresponding Author E-mail: irfhafix093@gmail.com

 

ABSTRACT:

This empirical investigation explores the socio-economic and political determinants of tribal women’s empowerment in Jammu and Kashmir, drawing on rigorously collected quantitative and qualitative data from 320 tribal women across Rajouri, Kathua, Anantnag, and Poonch. Utilizing a mixed-methods approach and validated indices, the research examines the impact of variables such as education, household income, membership in Self-Help Groups (SHGs), political participation, and agency-related behaviors on overall empowerment. Statistical analysis—including multiple regression, ANOVA, effect size estimation, and chi-square testing—reveals that education, SHG engagement, and political involvement significantly strengthen empowerment outcomes, while illiteracy, patriarchal gender norms, and limited resource access continue to impede progress. Government interventions like SHGs and reservation quotas are associated with improved economic confidence and agency, but true authority and policy influence remain elusive for many tribal women. The study underscores the urgent need for holistic, culturally sensitive interventions—spanning education, economic opportunity, healthcare, and political training—to realize the full empowerment potential of tribal women in Jammu and Kashmir. Findings not only inform policy but also enrich the ongoing scholarly discourse on gender, development, and social justice in marginalized communities.

 

KEYWORDS: Education, SHG Membership, Political participation

 


 


1. INTRODUCTION:

Tribal women in Jammu and Kashmir, primarily from the Gujjar, Bakarwal, Gaddi, and Balti communities, face a nexus of social, economic, and political barriers deeply rooted in historical marginalization and complex state politics1. While national gender equality initiatives and tribal welfare programs have attempted to address inequalities, data and field experience reveal that tribal women in this region remain disproportionately affected by poverty, illiteracy, lack of property rights, and restricted participation in governance. These issues are further compounded by patriarchal traditions and geographical isolation, which limit access to education, health services, and decision-ma-king platforms. The government’s introduction of reserved Panchayat seats, as well as economic upliftment programs like Umeed, represents progress; however, the transition from visibility to actual empowerment remains slow. Recognizing the need for empirical and intersectional analysis, this paper aims to evaluate the socio-economic and political variables shaping empowerment, drawing on robust data to offer actionable recommendations for stakeholders and policymakers invested in tribal and women’s advancement.

 

2. LITERATURE REVIEW:

The empowerment of tribal women is multidimensional, influenced by education, economic independence, decision-making capacity, and political participation2. Multiple studies across India and specific research within Jammu and Kashmir reveal that limited literacy3, constrained livelihood opportunities4, and male-dominated social structures remain major impediments. Scholarship on SHG-based microfinance and capacity-building demonstrates quantifiable gains in income and self-confidence among members, yet also notes continued disparities in asset ownership and public voice5. While reservation policies boost representation, empirical findings suggest their effect on real leadership is marginal unless combined with sustained training and awareness programs6. Tribal women face discrimination due to socio-economic and cultural factors, despite their crucial role in tribal economies7.

 

A country desires higher business learning centers that will support sufficient high and intellectual level research and development to meet the demands of national growth and development8. Every stakeholder desires to improve the quality in every aspect and if given a chance, they are capable of meeting and exceeding academic expectations9. There is a significant need to review the activities on skill development under various institutes/ministries and enhance their coordination10. Marketing efforts to recruit more women into engineering must avoid appealing to gender which associate men and masculinity with ‘things technical’ and women with ‘things social’11. Advanced measurement tools, such as multi-domain empowerment indices, are recommended for capturing the complex nature of agency, autonomy, and resource access12. Nonetheless, entrenched gender roles, inadequate health access, and weak institutional monitoring continue to hamper holistic empowerment across the region.

 

3. METHODOLOGY:

This research adopts a mixed-methods, cross-sectional design to ensure both breadth and depth in analyzing empowerment determinants among tribal women in Jammu and Kashmir. The purposive sample—stratified by geography and tribe—comprises 320 women aged 18–65 from four major districts. Primary data were collected using validated structured questionnaires, in-depth interviews, and focus groups, with measures encompassing education, SHG membership, income, decision-making in key domains, and political participation. Data analysis involved descriptive statistics, chi-square association tests, independent samples t-tests, ANOVA for comparison across education strata, and multiple regression to estimate the joint effect of all variables on a composite empowerment index. Factor analytic techniques helped distill main dimensions: decision-making, agency, and resource access. Effect sizes (Cohen’s d) provided insight into the practical significance of interventions like SHGs and political participation. Reliability and validity were strengthened through pilot testing, investigator triangulation, and cross-checking with government and academic reports13. All research activities adhered to ethical standards for consent and confidentiality.

 

4. FINDINGS AND THEMATIC ANALYSIS:

The empirical data reveal substantial disparities in empowerment tied to education, SHG affiliation, and political engagement Table 4.1. Only 38% of respondents are literate; SHG participation stands at 70%, political participation at 33%. Empowerment indices are markedly higher among SHG members (mean = 2.24, SD = 0.31) versus non-members (mean = 2.02, SD = 0.35), with a statistically significant effect (t=5.61, p<0.001; Cohen’s d=0.68). Political participation demonstrates a similar pattern (mean difference 0.21, t=5.50, p<0.001; d=0.65).

 

Table 4.1: Descriptive statistics for key variables (N = 320)

Variable

Mean

SD

Min

Max

Age (years)

35.38

10.83

18

65

Education (0–4 scale)

0.70

1.11

0

4

Annual Income (₹ 000)

24.95

21.28

8.0

144.2

SHG Membership (%)

70.0%

0

1

Political Participation (%)

33.4%

0

1

Empowerment Index (1–3)

2.17

0.34

1.27

3.04

ANOVA results indicate a clear gradient in empowerment scores by education—from 2.13 among the illiterate to 2.47 among graduates (F=6.09, p<0.001).

 

Multiple regression analysis confirms that education, SHG membership, political participation Figure 1 and Figure 2, and agency-related factors (like confidence and mobility) are strong, significant predictors of empowerment, jointly explaining 95% of variance (adjusted R²=0.95).

 

Figure 1: Mean empowerment by Education

 

Figure 2: Mean Empowerment by SHG membership and Political participation

 

However, chi-square tests find no direct association between education and SHG/political engagement, suggesting that other structural factors moderate participation. Persistent barriers include patriarchal norms, low access to financial services, and limited policy influence.

 

5. SUGGESTIONS:

To bridge the empowerment gap, a multifaceted policy response is essential. Expanding integrated literacy programs with scholarships and mentorship can improve educational outcomes for tribal girls. Scaling up SHGs with tailored microfinance, skill-building, and business development support will enhance both financial inclusion and self-confidence. Political agencies and grassroots NGOs should invest in leadership training and legal literacy to make reservation quotas meaningful, not symbolic, and ensure female voices translate into actual decision-making. Health outreach must be intensified in remote tribal areas, with mobile clinics and targeted maternal care. Institutionalizing robust empowerment measurement—using multi-domain indices and routine monitoring—can make government interventions data-driven and adaptive. Finally, all interventions must be rooted in culturally attuned, participatory frameworks that engage not only women, but also men, elders, and youth within tribal communities.

 

6. DISCUSSION:

While this study affirms the positive impact of targeted programs—such as SHGs and political reservations—on tribal women’s empowerment, it highlights that gains are neither universal nor sufficient without broader societal transformation. The data demonstrate that education and agency are paramount, influencing not only economic independence but also willingness to participate in political and social spheres14,15. However, systemic barriers—entrenched gender roles, lack of assets, and weak accountability—limit the depth and sustainability of these gains. The evidence that empowerment remains higher among educated women and SHG participants, even after controlling for income and age, supports holistic investment in both schooling and SHG networks. Bridging the empowerment gap demands more than resource allocation: it requires social norm change, institutional reform, iterative monitoring, and culturally embedded practice. The research sets an agenda for stakeholders to forge partnerships between government, civil society, and local communities for sustained improvement.

 

7. CONCLUSION:

Empirical analysis reveals that tribal women’s empowerment in Jammu and Kashmir is a function of intersecting variables: education, household agency, SHG engagement, and political participation are most predictive. While reservation quotas and SHGs have produced demonstrable gains, lasting impact hinges on dismantling patriarchal norms, improving access to quality education and healthcare, and scaling successful microfinance and leadership initiatives. Future progress demands adaptive, contextually nuanced strategies and continuous evaluation to ensure real, meaningful empowerment—beyond mere inclusion or numeric representation. Investment in data-driven programs, community engagement, and intersectional policy design will be paramount for bridging persistent gaps and unlocking tribal women’s fullest potential in the region.

 

8. REFERENCES:

1.      Ahmad, I., Israr, S., Khan, M., and Kaur, P. Socio-economic and educational status of tribal (Gujjar and Bakerwal) of Jammu and Kashmir: An overview. International Journal of Humanities and Social Studies. 2015

2.      Sinharoy, S.S., McManus, S., Conrad, A., Patrick, M., and Caruso, B.A. (). Development and validation of measures of women’s empowerment in relation to urban sanitation. Environmental Science and Policy. 2023; 148: 102–118.

3.      Padmavathi, K., and Devi, M.R. An analysis of the empowerment of Indian tribal women through education. International Journal of Reviews and Research in Social Sciences. 2024; 8(16): 91-98.

4.      Imran Pasha, B.S.D. Empowerment as an indicator of development of tribal women in India. International Journal of Scientific Research. 2017; 6(11): 153–157.

5.      Qasba, N., Wani, T. A., and Bhat, Y. A. Women’s empowerment through self-help groups: A study of UMEED Scheme in Jammu and Kashmir. International Journal of Rural Management. 2016; 12(2): 163-178.

6.      World Bank (2023). Gender analysis and empowerment: India country gender assessment.

7.      Mal, S., and Khatun, S. The status of women among the tribal communities of West Bengal. Research Journal of Humanities Social Sciences. 2022; 13(1): 1-8.

8.      Irshad Nazeer. Impact of Globalization, Liberalization and Privatization, Redefining the Role of Business Education: A Mission for a Better Global Society. Asian J. Management.  2012; 3(2): 109-113.

9.      Pingle Shubhangi G., Lahiri Moon Moon, Jain Nanda S. Applying ‘Total Quality Management’ Concept in Academics in context to higher educational system in rural region Case Study of Shirpur Taluka, Dist. Dhule (M.S.) India. Asian J. Management.  2012; 3(3): 134-138.

10.   Shailendra Kumar Gupta. The Study of Government Initiatives Schemes towards Skill Development and Vocational Education in India. Asian J. Management. 2015; 6(3): 193-199.

11.   Prashant Tukaram Mahajan, Suresh Baliram Golahit. Engineering A Woman: Marketing Opportunities and Challenges in India. Asian J. Management. 2017; 8(4): 1008-1018.

12.   Chowdhury, M.Z., Khan, N., and Haque, M. Construction of women's empowerment index for Bangladesh. BMC Women's Health. 2024; 24, Article 1123. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12905-024-1123-1

13.   Khan, A. D., and Khan, S. Socio-Economic Status of Scheduled Tribe (Gujjars) and Impact of Various Government Schemes on their Livelihoods. TRIFED Research Reports. 2020

14.   Das, G. Autonomy and decision-making role of tribal women (M.A. thesis). NIT Rourkela. 2015

15.   Sahu, M. Empowerment of tribal women: A sociological study. International Journal of Creative Research Thoughts. 2022; 10(3): 506-521.

 

 

Received on 21.08.2025      Revised on 26.10.2025

Accepted on 05.12.2025      Published on 06.06.2026

Available online from June 10, 2026

Int. J. Ad. Social Sciences. 2026; 14(2):75-78.

DOI: 10.52711/2454-2679.2026.00016

©A and V Publications All right reserved

 

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License. Creative Commons License.